What If: The Question That Opens Everything

“What if” is two words.
It is also one of the most generative tools in any creative, strategic, or design practice. The problem is that most people use it wrong, which is to say, they use it to generate worry rather than possibility.
“What if I fail?”
“What if they say no?”
“What if this doesn’t work?”
These are “What If” questions, technically, but they already know where they’re going.
What if we changed the story?
Popular culture has been exploring this question for generations.
Marvel’s What If…? (2021) animated series takes familiar characters and changes pivotal moments in their stories. What if Peggy Carter became the first super soldier instead of Steve Rogers? What if T’Challa became Star-Lord? Each question changes an established assumption and opens an entirely different reality.
Frank Capra’s It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) explores a more personal question. What if George Bailey had never been born? By removing one person from his community, the film reveals the extraordinary consequences of seemingly ordinary choices and relationships.
And The Man in the High Castle (2015), based on Philip K. Dick’s 1962 novel, asks a much darker question: What if the Axis powers had won World War II? That single change creates an alternative history with profound political, cultural, and personal consequences.
These examples are very different, but they share something important. None begins by accepting the familiar world as inevitable. Each changes something we assume to be true and explores what follows. I explored similar ideas in The Futures We Pass: How Some Films Show Us “What If”, looking at how different choices and chance encounters can create entirely different futures.
What a good “What If” question does
A well-formed “What If” question opens a possibility space that you couldn’t access by thinking straightforwardly about your current situation. It does this by suspending one or more assumed constants, things you’re treating as fixed, and asking what follows if they’re not.
“What if my organization operated without a hierarchy?” is a good “What If” question. It suspends a constant that most organizations treat as physics and asks what the world looks like without it.
You might conclude that it wouldn’t work, but you’d arrive at that conclusion after genuinely imagining the alternative. This means you now understand why the hierarchy exists in a way you didn’t before.
The goal is not necessarily to find the right answer. It is to discover possibilities, implications, and assumptions that were previously invisible.
As I explored in Scenarios: Insight vs. Warning, scenarios can help us understand possible futures or motivate action to avoid particular outcomes. A good “What If” question can serve either purpose, but it should begin by allowing us to explore rather than immediately judge.
The test of a good “What If” question
Three criteria:
- Is it specific enough to generate real implications? Vague “What Ifs” generate vague thinking.
- Is it open enough that you genuinely don’t know where it goes? If you already know the answer, it’s not a question, it’s a setup.
- Does it challenge an assumption strongly enough to change how you see the problem? The question should reveal something you hadn’t considered.
The most valuable questions are sometimes uncomfortable. Others are playful or absurd. What they share is an ability to make the familiar unfamiliar.
A question that initially sounds ridiculous might reveal something important precisely because nobody has taken it seriously before.
Turning worry into possibility
The difference often comes down to how we frame the question.
Consider these familiar worries and how they might become more generative:
- What if I lose my job? What if my next career doesn’t resemble my current one?
- What if my idea fails? What if failure reveals a different opportunity?
- What if AI replaces my work? What if AI changes what human work is most valuable?
- What if nobody likes my idea? What if I’m presenting it to the wrong audience?
The first questions focus on a feared outcome. The second questions open possibilities worth exploring.
This doesn’t mean negative possibilities should be ignored. Asking what might go wrong is essential to risk management and preparation. But if every question begins and ends with fear, we’re limiting our ability to imagine something different.
How to generate them
- Identify something you’re currently treating as a fixed fact.
- Ask what would follow if it weren’t.
- Write it as a complete sentence beginning with “What if.” Don’t evaluate it yet.
- Generate five before you start assessing. The fifth one is usually better than the first.
You can do this with a career decision, an organizational challenge, a creative project, or even a personal relationship.
The exercise is not about predicting what will happen. It’s about discovering what could happen if the rules were different.
In Every Portal Changes the Rules, I explored how crossing into an unfamiliar world forces us to reconsider what we know and how we act. A good “What If” question can create a similar experience without requiring us to leave the world we’re in.
It lets us explore the other side before deciding whether to step through.
The “What If” question is not a prediction. It’s a key. The room it opens is the scenario. What you find in the room is the insight.
So here’s a question to leave you with: What is one thing in your life or work that you’ve stopped questioning because you’ve accepted it as a fact?
What if it weren’t?